Sunday, February 2, 2020

Placeholders for missing images


If a data source doesn't contain images for certain items, what is the best way to indicate that the image used is a placeholder image?



The type of placeholder image would probably alter dependant on the type of image that should be there. For example if its a missing image of a person then a silhouetted image of a person would probably be used. But what if its a generic image whereby I don't want to indicate the type of image that's missing, only that this particular item doesn't have its own image.


Any thoughts?


EDIT/ADDITION


Ok lets get into specifics then. Lets assume a placeholder is needed. it has to be a generic placeholder i.e. no human silhouette or identicon or file type. Is the best solution a variation on the flat grey mountain and sun icon? I believe it is but what are peoples thoughts on this?



Answer



I believe it depends on content too much to give a single answer.



what is the best way to indicate that the image used is a placeholder image?



Generally, you want it to be easy to tell the placeholder from the real thing. So if the expected image is a photo, do not use a photographic image as a placeholder, but rather an icon.



Always make sure that the placeholder matches the style and colors of the system, visually showing that this piece of graphic is a part of the program controls, not a part of the user contents, or perhaps just leave the space empty.


Some variations:




  • Layout does not necessarily require a placeholder. Not finding a good example right now, so this menu will have to do:


    enter image description here



  • Containers can be used so that it does not matter whether there is an image inside or not (Empty folder below)


  • Icons: could be used, depending on the situation, just like the silhouette you mention, or the Empty Image below:



    enter image description here




Edit/Addition (see question)


If the image that needs a placeholder is the type of image that actually could be The Sun and the Mountain, then yes, using that metaphor would work.


If the image, when existing, rather would be a picture of a tool (a hammer), a shape (a polygon, a border, a rounded corner), an organism (an amoeba), then pick another metaphor accordingly.


If you really need a placeholder image/icon for your "generic image", then the job starts in finding that metaphor, and many systems find The Sun and the Mountain appropriate.


No comments:

Post a Comment

technique - How credible is wikipedia?

I understand that this question relates more to wikipedia than it does writing but... If I was going to use wikipedia for a source for a res...