What is a more intuitive way to present a 3-option toggle?

Stack Exchange's tag popup card/thingy has a star which you can toggle between "Favorite" (gold star), "Ignored" (red cross), and "Normal" (grey star).

Favorite:

Ignored:

Normal:

This is not intuitive at all, thanks to the grey star meaning "Normal." One would expect a 2-option toggle when clicking on it results in the star becoming gold.

What is a better way to present this?

---

For those who are interested for accessibility reasons, here's the HTML code:

 
  ★ 
  5 followers 

  subscribe 
  | rss

(The anchor tag has a class that cycles through tm-favorite, tm-favorite-ignore, and tm-favorite-clear.)